Skip to content
Mind Flaws

Judgment & Decision · Quick Test

Bat and Ball

Why does such a simple sum fool so many people?

The experiment

Read the problem and answer with the first number that comes to mind.

A bat and a ball cost $1.10 in total. The bat costs $1.00 more than the ball. How much does the ball cost?
cents

What happened?

The answer that pops into your head is 10 cents. It feels obvious, but it is wrong: if the ball cost 10 cents, the bat would cost $1.10 and the total would be $1.20. The right answer is 5 cents (ball) plus $1.05 (bat).

Why does your brain do this?

Your mind has a fast mode, which gives automatic answers, and a slow mode, which checks and calculates. Here, “$1.10 minus $1.00” gives such a neat answer that the slow mode is never called in. Getting it wrong is not a lack of intelligence: it is not doubting your first idea.

When does this shortcut work well?

Answering fast is great when the situation is familiar and a mistake costs little, like working out simple change or picking the shortest checkout line. If you calmly checked everything, there would be no time left for anything else.

Where does it show up in daily life?

“Buy 3, pay for 2” deals, installment interest and headlines with eye-catching numbers call for the same pause. When an answer seems too easy, it is worth spending ten seconds checking it.

Deep Dive

Open Nerd Mode

The problem first appeared in 2002, in a chapter by Daniel Kahneman and Shane Frederick on intuitive judgment. In Frederick’s data, as reported by Kahneman, 50% of Princeton students and 56% of University of Michigan students answered 10 cents.

Frederick later included the problem in the Cognitive Reflection Test (CRT), published in 2005. The test has three questions, and each one suggests a wrong intuitive answer. Frederick linked test scores to risk and time preferences in decisions.

A meta-analysis by Brañas-Garza, Kujal and Lenkei (2019), with 118 studies and more than 44,000 participants in 21 countries, examined who does better and under which conditions. It found that paying for correct answers does not improve performance and that university students score higher than other people.

As Pennycook and colleagues (2016) summarize, most wrong answers are exactly the intuitive one (10 cents), not just any mistake. The technical terms are type 1 processing (fast, automatic) and type 2 (slow, deliberate), from dual-process theory.

Technical terms

  • Intuition
  • Cognitive reflection

Discovery

Described by Shane Frederick in 2002.

Level of evidence

Robust evidence

Replicated in multi-lab studies or consistent meta-analyses.

Basis: Brañas-Garza, P.; Kujal, P.; Lenkei, B. (2019). Cognitive reflection test: Whom, how, when.

References

  1. Original studyFrederick, S. (2005). Cognitive reflection and decision making. Journal of Economic Perspectives, 19(4), 25–42.
  2. Original studyKahneman, D.; Frederick, S. (2002). Representativeness revisited: Attribute substitution in intuitive judgment. Heuristics and Biases: The Psychology of Intuitive Judgment (Cambridge University Press), 49–81.
  3. Original studyKahneman, D. (2003). Maps of bounded rationality: A perspective on intuitive judgment and choice. Les Prix Nobel 2002 (Nobel Foundation), 449–489.
  4. ReviewBrañas-Garza, P.; Kujal, P.; Lenkei, B. (2019). Cognitive reflection test: Whom, how, when. Journal of Behavioral and Experimental Economics, 82, 101455.
  5. ReplicationPennycook, G.; Cheyne, J. A.; Koehler, D. J.; Fugelsang, J. A. (2016). Is the cognitive reflection test a measure of both reflection and intuition? Behavior Research Methods, 48(1), 341–348.

Review

This text has not been reviewed by a volunteer yet. Want to help review it?

Found a mistake? Write to [email protected]