Skip to content
Mind Flaws

Judgment & Decision · Quick Test

Monty Hall Problem

Stick with your door or switch?

The experiment

Play one round. There is no trick in the rules.

On a TV show, there are three closed doors. Behind one is a car; behind the other two, goats. You pick a door. The host, who knows where the car is, always opens one of the other doors with a goat behind it and always offers a switch: you can stick with your door or switch to the other one that is still closed.

Three doors side by side, numbered 1 to 3. Open doors show what was behind them.
Which door do you pick?

What happened?

When you picked the first door, the chance that the car was behind it was 1 in 3, and the chance that it was behind one of the other two was 2 in 3. The host knows where the car is and never opens its door. So if the car was behind one of the other two, he opens the one with the goat and leaves the car behind the door that is left. Switching wins whenever your first pick was wrong, which happens 2 times in 3. Sticking wins only when your first pick was right: 1 time in 3.

Why does your brain do this?

With two doors closed, the mind thinks “it’s fifty-fifty” and sees no reason to switch. That reasoning would be right if the host opened a door at random, but he chooses knowing where the car is, and that choice carries information. It helps to imagine 100 doors: you pick one, and the host opens 98 with goats, leaving just one closed. Sticking with yours suddenly looks much less tempting. On top of that, losing after switching brings more regret than losing after sticking, and that weighs in favor of staying put.

When does this shortcut work well?

When two options are left and nobody chose which one to remove while knowing the answer, fifty-fifty is right. If the host opened a door at random and a goat happened to appear, sticking and switching would give the same chance. And keeping a well-thought-out choice, instead of changing it on impulse, is often a good rule.

Where does this show up in daily life?

Whenever someone who knows the answer rules out options, what is left is not fifty-fifty: the way that person chose what to rule out also counts. And the urge to keep your first choice, so you won’t regret having changed, shows up in many decisions, from the checkout line to an investment that no longer makes sense.

Nerd Mode

Open Nerd Mode

Statistician Steve Selvin posed the problem in a letter to The American Statistician in 1975, naming it after the host of an American TV game show. It became famous in 1990, when Marilyn vos Savant answered “switch” in her magazine column and received letters from readers, including people with math training, saying she was wrong.

The math depends on the rules. The answer “switching wins 2 in 3” holds when the host knows where the car is, always opens a door with a goat that you did not pick, and always offers the switch. That is why this page states the rules before you play.

A 2018 systematic review (Saenen and colleagues, 26 articles) concluded that the vast majority of people stick with their first door. In a study with participants from several countries, between 79% and 87% stuck. The review lists several possible reasons, such as believing that two doors means fifty-fifty, the illusion of control over the first pick, and the greater regret of losing after switching. Any one of them is enough to make a person get it wrong, which helps explain why the mistake is so common. After playing many rounds with feedback, people start switching more often, but in none of the studies reviewed did experience lead participants to switch on every round.

In 2010, Herbranson and Schroeder tested pigeons on a version of the game. After many rounds, the pigeons switched far more often than people did.

Here, “escaping the trap” means switching doors, whether or not the car shows up this round: the right move is the one that wins more often, and a single round comes down to luck.

Technical terms

  • Probability
  • Conditional probability
  • Intuition

Discovery

Described by Steve Selvin in 1975.

Level of evidence

Robust evidence

Replicated in multi-lab studies or consistent meta-analyses.

Basis: Saenen, L.; Heyvaert, M.; Van Dooren, W.; Schaeken, W.; Onghena, P. (2018). Why humans fail in solving the Monty Hall dilemma: A systematic review.

References

  1. Original studySelvin, S. (1975). A problem in probability (letter to the editor). The American Statistician, 29(1), 67.
  2. Original studyGranberg, D.; Brown, T. A. (1995). The Monty Hall dilemma. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 21(7), 711–723.
  3. Original studyHerbranson, W. T.; Schroeder, J. (2010). Are birds smarter than mathematicians? Pigeons (Columba livia) perform optimally on a version of the Monty Hall Dilemma. Journal of Comparative Psychology, 124(1), 1–13.
  4. ReviewSaenen, L.; Heyvaert, M.; Van Dooren, W.; Schaeken, W.; Onghena, P. (2018). Why humans fail in solving the Monty Hall dilemma: A systematic review. Psychologica Belgica, 58(1), 128–158.

Review

This text has not been reviewed by a volunteer yet. Want to help review it?

Found a mistake? Write to [email protected]