Skip to content
Mind Flaws

Self & Social Bias · Quick Test

Optimism Bias

Do bad things happen to other people more than to you?

The experiment

For each situation, move the slider to your answer. There is no right answer.

Compared with other people of your age and sex, what is the chance that each situation below will happen to you someday? Answer with how much smaller or larger your chance is than these people's average.

Average
Average
Average
Average
Average
Average

What happened?

You compared your chance of six bad things happening with that of people like you. A single person may really be below average: non-smokers are less likely to get lung cancer. But in a large group, the average of the differences should be close to zero. In the original study, it was well below zero: almost everyone saw themselves as safer than their classmates.

Why does your brain do this?

To judge your own chance, the mind recalls what you do to avoid the problem: you drink little, you take care of your health, you are good at your job. What other people do stays invisible, so they seem more exposed. Picturing something bad happening to you is also unpleasant, and the mind prefers not to dwell on it.

When does this shortcut work well?

A little optimism helps you start projects, keep going after a failure and take risks that are worth it, like opening a business or moving to a new city. People who expect a good outcome tend to work harder to get there. And for rare events, thinking it probably won’t happen to you is often right.

Where does it show up in daily life?

It shows up in people who drive after drinking because “it won’t happen to me”, who skip insurance or backups, who don’t wear sunscreen, and who plan a renovation or a project assuming nothing will go wrong. A practical check is to ask: what usually happens to people in the same situation as me?

Nerd Mode

Open Nerd Mode

Neil Weinstein (1980) asked 258 Rutgers students in the US to compare their own chance of experiencing 42 events with that of other students of the same sex, on a scale from “100% less (no chance)” to “5 times average”, the same one used here. In 37 of the 42 events, the average leaned in the optimistic direction. For negative events, the overall average was −20.4%; for positive ones, +15.4%. Having a drinking problem (−58.3%) and getting divorced (−48.7%) were among the most optimistic. In a second study, reading the lists of precautions other students said they took reduced the optimism, but did not eliminate it.

The evidence badge here is contested. Adam Harris and Ulrike Hahn (2011) showed that this method produces negative averages even from people with no bias at all. For a rare event like lung cancer, the great majority of people really do have less chance than average, because the average is pulled up by the minority who will get the disease. That minority cannot make up for it on a scale with a ceiling, and the group average falls below zero without anyone being wrong. Add to that the small sample of the minority and the tendency of imprecise estimates to drift toward the middle of the scale.

One clue in favor of the critique is in the 1980 table itself: “marrying someone wealthy”, a good but rare event, also came out below average (−9.1%), which would be pessimism. In five studies that controlled for these effects, Harris and colleagues (2017) found no sign of genuine optimism. So the result here only compares your average with the study’s: it does not measure whether you are too optimistic, or whether your real chance is higher or lower.

Technical terms

  • Self-assessment
  • Social comparison

Discovery

Described by Neil D. Weinstein in 1980.

Level of evidence

Contested evidence

Major replications have failed or there is a strong alternative explanation.

Basis: Harris, A. J. L.; de Molière, L.; Soh, M.; Hahn, U. (2017). Unrealistic comparative optimism: An unsuccessful search for evidence of a genuinely motivational bias.

References

  1. Original studyWeinstein, N. D. (1980). Unrealistic optimism about future life events. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 39(5), 806–820.
  2. ReviewHarris, A. J. L.; Hahn, U. (2011). Unrealistic optimism about future life events: A cautionary note. Psychological Review, 118(1), 135–154.
  3. ReplicationHarris, A. J. L.; de Molière, L.; Soh, M.; Hahn, U. (2017). Unrealistic comparative optimism: An unsuccessful search for evidence of a genuinely motivational bias. PLOS ONE, 12(3), e0173136.

Review

This text has not been reviewed by a volunteer yet. Want to help review it?

Found a mistake? Write to [email protected]