Skip to content
Mind Flaws

Judgment & Decision · Quick Test

Wason Selection Task

To test a rule, which cards do you need to turn over?

The experiment

Read the rule, look at the cards and choose which ones to turn over.

Each card has a letter on one side and a number on the other. You can see only one side of each.

Rule: if a card has a D on one side, then it has a 3 on the other side.

Which cards do you need to turn over to find out whether the rule holds for these four cards? Select only the ones you need.

What happened?

Most people turn over the D, or the D and the 3. But the 3 does not help: the rule does not say every 3 has a D behind it, so any letter there is allowed. The card that can break the rule is the 7: if there is a D behind it, the rule is false. The right cards are D and 7, and few people get there.

Why does your brain do this?

Reading “D” and “3” in the rule, the mind pictures cases where the rule holds, with a D and a 3 together, and looks for those cards. It is a search for examples, not counterexamples. Thinking about what would make the rule false, a D without a 3, takes more effort, because it means picturing something the rule does not mention: the 7.

When does this shortcut work well?

Looking for examples is a good start for understanding a new idea, and many everyday rules are true most of the time. When the rule is about something familiar, like a social norm, reasoning improves a lot: instead of testing an abstract rule, people look for whoever is breaking it, and the counterexample becomes easy to see.

Where does this show up in daily life?

Someone who believes “every time I wash my car, it rains” remembers the times they washed it and it rained, but does not look for the times they washed it and it was sunny. The same happens when testing a suspicion, a hunch about a coworker or a theory about a product. The helpful question is: what would I need to see to find out I am wrong?

Deep Dive

Open Nerd Mode

Peter Wason created the task in 1968 to see whether people understood the importance of looking for what could falsify a rule. The rule was the same as in this experiment: if there is a D on one side, there is a 3 on the other. People tended to choose the D alone, or the D and the 3, and rarely the D and the 7. The result was shocking at the time and led, over 50 years, to more than 300 published experiments.

In 2017, Marco Ragni, Ilir Kola and Philip Johnson-Laird gathered the experiments that reported the four most common selections. In the 104 with abstract rules, like this one, 39% of the choices were D and 3, 36% the D alone, 5% D, 3 and 7, and only 19% the right answer, D and 7 (percentages among those four selections). In 44 experiments with everyday rules, the right answer rose to 29%. In 80 with rules of obligation, such as “if a person is drinking beer, then the person must be over 19 years of age”, 64% chose the cards that could reveal someone breaking the rule.

The same team showed that the cards are not chosen one by one, independently: the combinations are more predictable than they would be if each card were decided on its own. This rules out several of the 15 theories proposed for the task. In their account, intuition, guided by the cases the rule describes, leads people to choose examples of it, and deliberation leads them to look for counterexamples. The full version of the meta-analysis, published in 2018, covered 228 experiments.

Technical terms

  • Logic
  • Hypothesis testing
  • Intuition

Discovery

Described by Peter Wason in 1968.

Level of evidence

Robust evidence

Replicated in multi-lab studies or consistent meta-analyses.

Basis: Ragni, M.; Kola, I.; Johnson-Laird, P. N. (2017). The Wason selection task: A meta-analysis.

References

  1. Original studyWason, P. C. (1968). Reasoning about a rule. Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology, 20(3), 273–281.
  2. ReplicationRagni, M.; Kola, I.; Johnson-Laird, P. N. (2017). The Wason selection task: A meta-analysis. Proceedings of the 39th Annual Meeting of the Cognitive Science Society, 980–985.
  3. ReplicationRagni, M.; Kola, I.; Johnson-Laird, P. N. (2018). On selecting evidence to test hypotheses: A theory of selection tasks. Psychological Bulletin, 144(8), 779–796.

Review

This text has not been reviewed by a volunteer yet. Want to help review it?

Found a mistake? Write to [email protected]